Instagram Told Us How It Ranks Content. Most Hotel Feeds Are Ignoring It.

If your hotel's feed is a steady rotation of slow pans across the pool, drone shots of the coastline, and captions like "Your view awaits," you're in good company. That's the issue. Almost every upscale hotel on Instagram looks like that right now, and Instagram just explained, in plain language, why that content isn't getting reach.

In September, Adam Mosseri, the head of Instagram, posted a four-part video series on how and why Instagram ranks content. You can watch Part 1 here, and the rest are on his account. None of it is a secret formula. But it's the clearest on-the-record explanation we've had in years. Read it as a hotel marketer, and it lands as a pretty direct critique of how most properties are still posting.

How Does Instagram Decide What Content to Show?

Mosseri's first point is that no single algorithm exists. Feed, Stories, Reels, and Explore each rank content differently. Each format also delivers two distinct types of content: posts from your established network and external recommendations.

The logic underneath is simple. Instagram looks at what you've done on the app and predicts how likely you are to like a post, comment, send it to a friend, or watch a video to the end. Each prediction becomes a relevancy score, and posts get ordered by that score. Recency matters a lot, so feeds stay roughly chronological, but not strictly.

What this means for hotels: Instagram isn't judging whether your post is pretty. It's predicting whether a specific person will do something with it. A gorgeous sunset that nobody sends, saves, or watches to the end is, as far as the system is concerned, a post nobody wanted.

What Are Instagram's Content Principles?

In Part 2, Mosseri laid out four principles Instagram uses beyond those engagement predictions. Three of them matter for hotels. The fourth, model size, is about Instagram's AI getting smarter, and you can't do anything about it.

Originality
Instagram wants the person who made the content to get the reach, not the account that reposted it. That isn't new, but they're enforcing it harder. In April, Instagram extended its originality rules to photos and carousels, not just Reels. If most of what an account posts is someone else's content, that account becomes ineligible for recommendations. That means no reach to people who don't already follow you.

Recency
Instagram wants to reflect what's happening now. Mosseri said the company has worked to shrink the lag between something happening in the world and showing up in feeds. For a hotel, that's an open invitation. What's happening at your property this week? In your destination? The festival in town, the first cold morning on the patio, the chef testing a new menu item. Shoot it while it's happening.

Breaking Content
This is the one hotels should be most encouraged by. Instagram deliberately "auditions" content from public accounts to small groups of people who don't follow them. If a post outperforms what Instagram expected, it gets shown again, and again, and it can reach hundreds of thousands of people.

You don't need a massive following to get massive reach. But you only get the audition once per post, and that first test group decides whether it goes anywhere.

Why Don't Promotional Hotel Posts Perform Organically?

Here's a real caption from a high-performing resort's organic post. We're not naming the property because we've written captions like this ourselves when clients asked. Paraphrased: "more room to unwind and reconnect, upgraded rooms with spacious living areas, thoughtful in-room amenities, curated floral arrangements to make your stay special, and a link to reserve."

Now picture that post going out to its audition group of strangers. Who sends it to a friend? Who watches to the end? Who stops at all? That caption could belong to any hotel in any city on the planet, and the people in that test group can tell.

To be clear, Instagram hasn't said it penalizes promotional content. It doesn't need to. The system rewards what people interact with, and almost nobody interacts with an offer they didn't ask for. Nobody has ever sent their best friend a room upgrade package.

That's the old-school thinking we still run into constantly. Hotels treat organic social like a free billboard for packages and offers. Instagram has been pretty clear about where that content belongs: in ads.

As we covered last week, Meta now charges for links inside organic posts. Meta One's Advanced tier, at $49.99 a month in the US, lets you add links to up to four posts and four Reels each month. Even the "organic" route to a booking link runs through a paywall. Promote your offers. Just pay to do it, and save your organic feed for content people actually want.

Does Reposting UGC Still Work on Instagram?

Not the way most hotels have been doing it. Downloading a guest's or creator's photo and posting it as your own is exactly the behavior Instagram is now filtering out of recommendations. Those days are done.

That doesn't mean creator content is off the table. It means using the tools Instagram built for it:

• Collab posts with creators who visit your property, so the content lives on both accounts and credit goes to the person who made it.
• The Repost button for guest and creator content you love. It credits the original creator, and Mosseri has specifically pointed to it as the right way to share someone else's work.
• Remix, when you want to add your own take to someone else's Reel.

This is a big part of why we've shifted our own focus from user-generated content toward content we create on property, built around the people who work there.

What Does Original Hotel Content Look Like?

It's not more polish. Mosseri's principles all point the same direction: original, current, and interesting to someone who has never heard of your hotel.

We tested this with our own clients. On content visits where we were still shooting the photo and video each resort needed, we also pointed the camera at their associates. A real person, a real question, their own answer. Still shot well. Never trying to look like an ad. Here's what happened at three resorts:

• Resort one: 400+ organic interactions, the highest on the account, plus 100+ comments.
• Resort two: 206 interactions against an account average of 58.
• Resort three: 14,933 organic views, in the top 20% of the account's all-time posts, and more than 10 hours of total watch time. Only a paid ad beat that.

Three properties, three markets, three audiences, same pattern. That's not a lucky post. That's a format. And it lines up with exactly what Mosseri described: content people watch to the end, comment on, and pass along, because it shows them something they can't get from every other hotel feed.

How Should Hotels Measure Instagram Performance?

Mosseri's advice to creators applies just as much to hotel marketers. Stop looking at total views and likes, and look at rates. Of everyone who saw a post, what percentage liked it, sent it, or watched to the end? Rates tell you why one post beat another. Totals mostly tell you how many followers you have.

He also told creators to keep experimenting. What works today might not work in a year. Trial Reels are built for this. They're shown to non-followers first, so you can test a new format without your main feed taking the hit.

Before anything goes out, run it past three questions:

• Would someone who's never heard of your hotel want to watch this?
• Would it entertain them?
• Would it help them?

If the answer to all three is no, it's probably an ad. Run it as one.

Advice to Hotels

Move your packages and offers into paid, and give your organic feed back to content people would choose to watch. Make originality the rule: shoot your own content, and use Collabs and the Repost button for anything a guest or creator made. Put your people on camera and tie content to what's happening at your property and in your destination right now. Then judge it by rates, not totals.

We've been doing social for hotels for over 15 years, and Instagram has never been this direct about what it rewards. The properties that listen will get the reach. The ones posting "Your view awaits" will keep wondering where it went.

📰 Industry Intel

✈️ What's Happening at Casual Fridays